Panini Sandwiches Using an Air Fryer

Panini sandwiches are usually made with a panini press, but I’ve found that using an air fryer is easier and better. Here’s how to make a turkey and cheese panini sandwich in an air fryer.

Ingredients

  • 2 slices of turkey
  • 2 slices of mozzarella cheese
  • 2 slices of bread (sourdough, etc)
  • mayo

Instructions

  1. Preheat the air fryer to 400 F
  2. Spread mayo on one side of each slice of bread
  3. Assemble the sandwich as follows
Bread slice (mayo on outside)
Turkey slice
Cheese slices
Turkey slice
Bread slice (mayo on outside)
  1. When the air fryer is preheated, set the time to 10 minutes and place the sandwich inside
  2. After 5 minutes, flip the sandwich
  • Increase or decrease the frying time to suit

Here are some ingredient options for making different panini sandwiches. The ingredients are listed in the order of the sandwich layers.

Meatball and cheese panini

  • mayo
  • bread slice
  • meatballs cut in half
  • pizza sauce
  • mozzarella cheese slices
  • bread slices
  • mayo

Chicken and cheese panini

  • mayo
  • bread slice
  • grilled chicken strips or sliced lightly breaded chicken breast
  • pesto sauce
  • roasted tomato
  • mozzarella cheese slices
  • bread
  • mayo

Turkey and cheese panini

  • mayo
  • bread slice
  • turkey slice
  • cheese slices
  • tomato slices
  • turkey slice
  • bread
  • mayo

BBQ chicken and cheese panini

  • mayo
  • bread slice
  • cheese slice
  • shredded chicken
  • bbq sauce
  • bread
  • mayo

Kebab and cheese panini

  • mayo
  • bread slice
  • cheese slice
  • kebabs
  • tzatziki sauce
  • tomato
  • bread
  • mayo

Beef brisket and cheese panini

  • mayo
  • bread slice
  • cheese slice
  • beef brisket
  • bread
  • mayo

Corned beef and cheese panini

  • mayo
  • bread slice
  • cheese slice
  • corned beef
  • bread
  • mayo

Following are different types of pre-cooked meat you can put in your panini and their prices.

$13 / lb at Costco
$10 / lb at Costco
$8.48 / lb at Costco
$13 / lb at Costco
$14 / lb at Costco
$6 / lb at Costco
$3.32 / lb at Costco
$12 / lb at Costco
$5.60 / lb